Police-Involved Shooting Under Investigation in Carle Place, Nassau County

Carle Place, N.Y. — Nassau County police are conducting a full-scale investigation following a police-involved shooting in a residential neighborhood of Carle Place late Tuesday night. The incident has drawn attention from both local authorities and the New York Attorney General’s Office as questions remain about what led to the use of deadly force.

The Incident

According to police, the shooting took place around midnight near 339 Rushmore Avenue, a quiet street lined with family homes. The area was quickly blocked off with crime scene tape as detectives, homicide investigators, and emergency responders arrived on scene.

Neighbors reported being awakened by flashing lights and the sound of sirens as officers secured the perimeter. Hours later, crime scene units were still at the residence, documenting evidence and collecting witness statements.

While police confirmed that all responding officers are safe and unharmed, early reports indicate that the shooting resulted in serious injuries to an individual at the scene. A source familiar with the investigation told News 12 Long Island that one person has died, though this has not yet been officially confirmed by Nassau County police.

ABC7 Eyewitness News offered a slightly different account, reporting that a 30-year-old man was shot in the chest and transported to the hospital, with his condition not immediately clear.

Oversight and Investigation

In accordance with New York State law, the Attorney General’s Office of Special Investigation (OSI) has been called in to review the case. The OSI is required to investigate any incident in which a civilian dies or suffers serious injury during an interaction with law enforcement. Their presence highlights the seriousness of the matter and ensures transparency in the investigative process.

The Nassau County Police Department has not released details about what triggered the encounter, whether the individual involved was armed, or if any officers discharged their service weapons in response to a direct threat.

Impact on the Community

The location of the shooting has caused concern among local residents due to its close proximity to several schools, including Cherry Lane Primary School, Rushmore Avenue Intermediate School, and Carle Place High School. Though the incident occurred overnight, parents and community members expressed unease about violence so near to educational spaces.

Neighbors described Carle Place as a typically quiet community where such incidents are rare. “This is the last place you’d expect to see something like this,” said one longtime resident. “We’re all shaken, and we just want to know what really happened.”

What We Know So Far

• Time of Incident: Shortly after midnight, September 3, 2025

• Location: 339 Rushmore Avenue, Carle Place

• Officers’ Status: All responding officers unharmed

• Victim’s Status: Conflicting reports — one source says the individual has died; another states a man was hospitalized with a gunshot wound to the chest

• Investigators on Scene: Nassau County Homicide Squad, Crime Scene Unit, Attorney General’s OSI

• Community Impact: Close to three local schools, prompting safety concerns

Unanswered Questions

Authorities have not yet addressed key details, including:

• What led officers to the residence on Rushmore Avenue?

• Was the individual armed or threatening officers?

• What events immediately preceded the shooting?

• Has the victim’s identity been confirmed?

Conclusion

This is a developing story that underscores ongoing debates about police use of force and transparency in law enforcement. While officials continue to investigate, the Carle Place community is left seeking clarity. The involvement of the Attorney General’s Office ensures that the findings will be independently reviewed, but until more details are released, uncertainty remains.